The "list" thing came up again because I've given up hope finding my original CD of Nirvana - Unplugged In New York, so I finally downloaded the tracks. I can say that blatently, because I own the CD, so I don't mind downloading it off the net without paying. Plus, I don't really have the desire to pay crachwhore any royalities, but if Francis Bean is getting the money, then I'd consider it. Maybe in a trust.
Anyway, back to UINY. I was kind of a mainstream Nirvana fan back in the early to mid 90s, when the Seattle scene hit its stride. My friend Jesse introduced me to Nevermind, and MTV was the one that introduced me (and probably him) to Smells Like Teen Spirit. It was pretty cool, I enjoyed it, but ended up gravitating more to Pearl Jam during that time. I remember In Utero coming out, the shit that the band dealt with putting it out, and enjoying watching the band seemingly fuck with the label by doing everything that they didn't want them to do.
Then Kurt died.
Kurt died, and I heard about it driving back from college one day. It didn't really bother me too much, but the way it affected other people, I kind of was fascinated by it. Death only usually affects me by the affect it has on other people. Kurt's death was like that.
When I ended up working for The Wall later on, the winter of '94 had a few CDs in decent rotation in the store. UINY was one of them, and I remember when it was coming out that I was going to hate it, because it seemed like an attempt to capitalize on Kurt's death and the fact that the Christmas season was coming. There was talk at the time of two albums, actually, if I remember right. Only the one came out (From the Muddy Banks of the Wishkah came out two years later, and I'm not sure if even that was supposed to be the "other" album), and we played it a LOT at The Wall.
I wanted to hate it, to be honest. I wanted to hate Geffen and the whole idea of putting out something like this and either sell records because of Christmas or sell records because of someone's sudden death popularity. But UINY was haunting, I guess the best way to describe it. It didn't sound like Nirvana; in fact, most of the songs I didn't even realize were Nirvana songs until later looking them up. Yeah, I understand there were a lot of covers in there too, but even songs like Dumb and Polly didn't sounds like Nirvana songs. They sounded like this singer in a lot of pain, with a lot of the shit cut away.
This isn't to say by any means that Nirvana's Nevermind (or other studio albums) were shit, it's just that it's a different type of music. With the hard in-your-face sound, Nirvana came off as a "fuck you, fuck everybody" type of band, which is what a lot of people took them as, but listening to the lyrics and Kurt's gentle voice, cracking here and there with emotion, you saw a completely different artist, and you almost felt sorry for him. Knowing what he was going through at the time he made the album, it's hard to not feel sorry for him, going through the illness and withdrawls of heroin addiction.
Kurt and Layne Staley both died thanks to heroin addiction, some eight years seperate from each other, in totally different fashions. Kurt's death was at his own hand, unable to take the pain fron the heroin withdrawl, dying still at the height of popularity, before anyone really knew the type of pain he was going through. Staley's work in Alice In Chains got dark for periods of time, and looking back at their work, you see someone else who was mired in the midst of drug addiction. I wonder what path Nirvana would have taken had Kurt not killed himself, and whether he would have taken Nirvana in the path that Alice In Chains eventually followed, releasing music but not touring, until eventually pulling the band in seperate directions. Would AIC have been looked upon more legendarily (is that even a word?) if "Man In THe Box" been a little bit more up tempo, allowing MTV to build around that as the intro into the Seattle scene?
Funny how two parallels can turn so abruptly.